Sunday, June 28, 2015

The Curious Case of "The Watcher"

1--INTRO (Breaking of news story/National and Int'l news/Stalker claim)

On June 16, 2015 "The Courthouse News" posted a horrifying news article, reporting that a New Jersey family was forced to abandon their home due to threatening letters they received by an unknown person identifying himself only as "The Watcher". By June 24, the news spread to all major American news outlets, and was headlining in international news just as quickly. So far this fascinating story is being reported as a frightening case of stalking and harassment, though many commenters and bloggers are not buying the homeowners' claim that a stalker is responsible for the letters.

2--DETAILS of CASE (Lawsuit)

Various news sources have reported the basic facts in this case, though many important details are still unknown. Here is what we know so far:

On June 2, 2015 Derek and Maria Broaddus (the couple who purchased a home), officially filed a lawsuit against John and Andrea Woods (sellers of the home) for breach of contract. The Woods' had sold their house to the Broaddus family exactly one year previous. This lawsuit document (which I will from this point refer to as the "complaint"), provides most of the necessary facts.

The complaint states that the Broaddus family purchased "their dream home" at 657 Boulevard, Westfield, NJ for $1,355,657.00. The date of closing was June 2, 2014. In the complaint, the Broaddus' claim they received three disturbing and threatening letters from "The Watcher". The first creepy letter was received on June 5, 2014--just 3 days after the closing of the home sale. Here are the excepts known to be in the first letter, as reported in the complaint:

--"[the home] has been the subject of my family for decades"
--"I have be put in charge of watching and waiting for its second coming"
--"My grandfather watched the house in the 1920s and my father watched it in the 1960s. It is now my time."
--"Why are you here? I will find out"
--"Now that they have it to flaunt it, they pay the price"
--"Tsk, tsk, tsk...bad move. You don't want to make 657 Boulevard unhappy"
--"Do you need to fill the house with the young blood I requested?"
--"Once I know their names I will call to them and draw them too me"
--"I asked the Woods to bring me young blood"

The second letter was received June 18, and the third on July 18--both having similar content as the first, but these seem more threatening in tone. Here are the known excerpts from these two letters, as written in the complaint:

"

The Broaddus' claim they know that the Woods family also received a similar letter from "The Watcher", "on or about the week of May 26"--which predated the house's legal closing.  The Broaddus' are contending that this person "The Watcher", has by his actions stated in the letters, "made a claim" to the house, which might legally make the sale null and void in the State of New Jersey under justification that the seller did not offer a "marketable title" since the Woods' supposedly knew the house title was being challenged before the house sale was completed. The Broaddus' also claim the sale is null and void since the sellers knew of "The Watcher", yet failed to disclose that to the buyers.


3--THEORIES (real stalker?/movie deal hoax?/neighbors?/unsuccessful bidder?/former resident squatter?/scorned mistress?/homeowners?)
4--LEAD-IN to next blog entry (analysis of the letters--the only evidence!)

Friday, April 1, 2011

Ricky McCormick: Mysterious Death Encoded?












An Appeal by the FBI
On March 30, 2011, the FBI issued a call for cryptographers to assist their investigation of the supposed 1999 murder of one Ricky McCormick (pictured here). McCormick, 41, was found dead in a field near West Alton, MO in July 1999. On McCormick's person were two handwritten notes, both written in what appears to be a code or cipher. The FBI believes Ricky wrote these notes up to 3 days before his death; by releasing the notes (pictured below), the FBI hopes that a translation may help them figure out what happened to McCormick.


The Evidence
Ricky McCormick was last seen alive on June 25, 1999 when he visited Forest Park Hospital in St. Louis to obtain medication for chronic heart and lung problems. His dead body was found on Wednesday, June 30, 1999, lying near the southeast corner of a cornfield, not far from a wooded railroad bed just west of Highway 367. The body was decomposed to the point that the deceased had probably been dead for at least two days; his identity was confirmed by his fingerprint. At first it appeared as though McCormick may have had physical damage to his head, though the Coroner later found no evidence of obvious life-endangering injuries such as knife wounds or gunshots. Authorities remain uncertain as to whether Ricky was murdered or not; no cause of death was ever determined, and the body's advanced state of decomposition hindered their efforts. Some of the only evidence found at the scene were the two notes in McCormick's pocket, which were presumably written by him. West Alton Police and St. Charles County Police, in speaking with McCormick's parents, determined that family and friends knew Ricky had written messages in code since his youth. But no one claimed to have known how to read these codes.

Who was Ricky McCormick?
He was born in St. Louis in 1957 or 1958, and attended public school before dropping out of high school around 1975. Though Ricky quit school, family and friends described him as "street smart". Authorities determined that McCormick had three addresses in the St. Louis area, including 1400 Choteau Avenue in St. Louis, and several Illinois addresses. Missouri court records show that McCormick had financial trouble and was evicted from an apartment in the St. Louis area. Ricky had a criminal history in the area, including a charge of statutory rape, for which he served 11 months in jail. He was known to have fathered four children, though he never married. At the time of his death, McCormick was unemployed and living on disability welfare. McCormick's apparent reliance on writing codes for himself may indicate a private personality-- perhaps to hide information from others, or maybe to exercise a kind of personal intelligence.

Ricky's Writing Style
Authorities investigating Ricky's death could not find any other examples of Ricky's writing, besides the two notes found on his person. He was literate, and could not have made it to high school without being able to read and write in English.
The two pages exhibit similar writing, a right-leaning script using all capital letters, indicative of a literate, right-handed male. Both notes seem to have been written by the same hand. Each page's text is penned in strings of continuous characters--most being letters, but some numbers, parentheses, a few hyphens and one apostrophe. A character which appears to be "N" is written smaller and more quickly than other characters, and may represent not an "N" but rather something else, such as a line break. The letter "E" is the last letter of many "words" throughout the script, and many consonants are mixed in. Many "words" are repeated.
Despite the fact that many believe these passages to be in cipher or code, the text of both pages appear almost readable and may be written in a phonetic format. Again, Ricky was literate, so these two notes may represent a personal "shorthand" notation that Ricky developed. Let's now look at the text of the messages, before analyzing the code and shorthand possibilities, the "language" Ricky used in his writing.

Page 1
The page that authorities refer to as "Page 1" (noted by the circled "P1" in the upper-right hand corner of the page), appears to be written in ballpoint ink on a blank piece of unlined paper. The "message" fills up only the top half of the sheet of paper. Though most characters are strung together in 13 "lines" which appear to form "paragraphs", whole lines and portions of lines are encased in parentheses. The "title line" (top line) is indented, as are lines 7-13. The increasing indentations toward the end of this note give the appearance of songwriting, poetry or other lyrical notation of some sort.
Here is the Page 1 manuscript, typed in similar format and spacing to the actual page:

    (MNDMKNEARSE-N-S-M-KNARE)         (A(SM))
TFRHENPINSENPBSERCBBNSE NPRSE INC
PRSE N MRSE DPRE HLDWLDNCBE(TFXLF TCXL N CBE)
AL-PRPPIT XLYPPIY N CBE MGKSEWCDRCBRNSEPRSE
WLDRCBRNSE N T SSHENTXSE-CRSLE-CLTRSEWLDNCBE
ALWLDNCBETSME LRSE RLSE URGLNE AS N WLD N CBE
  (NOPFSE NLSRE NCBE) NTEGDDMNSENCURERCBRNE
              (TENE TFRNE NCBRTSE N CBE INC)
                       (FLRSE PQSE ONDE71 NCBE)
                       (CDNSE PRSE ONSDE74 NCBE)
                       (PRTSE PRSE ON REDE 75 N CBE)
(TF NQCMSP SOLE MRDE LUSE TOTE WLD N WLDNCBE)
                                           (194 WLD’S NCBE) (TRFXL)

Page 2
"Page 2", featuring what appear to be paragraphs that are circled and thus isolated from other paragraphs, was also written in ballpoint ink like Page 1. But this page's text was written on blank, unlined stationery marked "NOTES" at the top of the page. Page 2's stationery may have been old generic note paper (or a newer printing of a classic style), as evidenced by the "Art Deco" appearance of the font of "NOTES". This page's writing covers roughly the top 75% of the sheet.
Here is the Page 2 manuscript, typed in similar format and spacing to the actual page:

AL PNTE GLSE-SE ERTE
VLSE MTSE-CTSE-WSE-FRTSE
PNRTRSE ONDRSEWLD NCBE
NWLDZLRCMSPNEWLDSTSMEXL
         DULMT6TUNSE NCBEXC

          (MUNSAISTENMUNARSE)
KLSE-LRSTE-TRSE-TRSE-MKSEN-MRSE
          (SAE6NSE SE NMBSE)

NMNRCBRNSEPTE2PTEWSREBKNSE
26MLSE74SPRKSE29KENOSOLE173RTRSE
356LE CLGSEOUNUTKEDKRSE PSESHLE
651MTCSEHTLSENCUTCTRS NMRE
99.84.5 5UNEPLSENCRSEADLTSENSKSENBSE
NSREONSE PVTSEWLDNCBE (3XORL)
NMSENRSEIN2NTRLERCBRNSENTSRCRBNE
LSPNSENGSPSEMKSEKBSEPCBEAVXL’R
HMCRENMREFCBE          1/2MUNDPLSE
     D-W-M-4HIL XDRLX


Code or Shorthand?
Since the FBI's online posting of these two notes online on March 28, 2011, the notes have generated many theories of interpretation among the online community.The FBI and many others undoubtedly have been examining the texts for a code or cipher solution. Still others believe Ricky's work to be in a personal "shorthand" notation.

Code Theory
Some believe that these notes are written in code. One person found that part of the Page 2 code uses letters preceding the letter "N", and that these characters spell out "DEPEW", followed by an 877 area code phone number. This person found that "Depew" was the last name of a doctor working in a St. Louis area mental hospital, and that the phone number (decoded from counting the number position of letters in the alphabet), matches that of the mental facility.

Shorthand Theory
Others have come to see these cryptic messages as a form of shorthand, rather than a coded form of writing. Some think that these long "sentences" and "paragraphs" could rather be a list of part numbers, or job descriptions for repair work. Some point to the VIN-like appearance of sentences, and the terms "SL", "SE" and "XL" as maybe referring to certain automobiles. Others note the frequent appearance of letters "N", "S", and "E", as well as what might be highway/road or exit numbers, and believe these may be driving directions, written quickly in shorthand format as if Ricky were writing from someone's telephone dictation. Someone looked at the three farthest-indented lines of Page 1 and believed that perhaps these three lines listed certain people Ricky had some contact or experience with at certain times; the first (Line 9) appears to say "First person De(cember) (19)71 NCBE"; Line 10, "Second person De(cember) (19)74 NCBE". At least one observer has suggested that some "words" (like "NCBE") may refer to street names for illegal drugs, assuming that Ricky may have been dealing drugs and was keeping memos of customers, their orders and recognizable characteristics. Yet with all these shorthand theories, many internet sleuths are now focusing their attention on the possibility that these shorthand notes are song or poetry lyrics, as many words in sentences rhyme when spoken phonetically. Could he have been writing rap songs or making up song lyrics as many people often do? One internet sleuth posted a note to the "Ricky McCormick Murder Notes" Wikipedia page, giving a loose interpretation of the notes from "pigeon English" (the note was later disputed and deleted due to its lack of factual content). This contributor claims that McCormick wrote in a style similar to that of people with psychological problems, and his loose "phonetic" translation of the notes included many strange religious and/or mythical events and states of mind.
And some point out the possibility that McCormick's jumbled placement of letters within sentences, which complicates a straight phonetic interpretation of the writing, could reveal that the author was dyslexic.

Conclusion
The FBI's publishing of these two notes has prompted many interpretation efforts by the public online community, and this outpouring of ideas may eventually shed light on the mysterious death of Ricky McCormick. While the FBI stated its hope that someone will "decipher" the notes, it is unlikely they will be if indeed these notes are coded, as top cryptologists have failed to do so. If no "code key" or other writing examples were found among McCormick's belongings, the "code" will probably never be solved. Most likely the "code" is actually in a form of personalized phonetic and/or symbolic shorthand, which may not be so hard to decipher.
But in any case, I find it unfortunate that more details on Ricky McCormick's life and crime scene evidence have not been available via the internet. If more is revealed, law enforcement in Missouri as well as the FBI may be able to solve the mystery of Ricky's death with the help of the concerned public. I believe it is their only chance.

Wednesday, November 24, 2010

Death of Monika Rizzo--A Standoff With Police

May 1999: two years after Monika Rizzo's disappearance, the San Antonio Police still had not discovered enough evidence to warrant a murder charge against Leonard Rizzo, Sr. Monika's parents were distraught and frustrated with the inability to charge Monika's suspected killer.
Following the searches of the Rizzo home in 1997, Leonard Rizzo, Jr. (who lived across town from his father and brother Vincent), suddenly died of cancer. With his passing, the SAPD lost a key potential witness against his father, their main suspect in Monika's murder.

Just as it seemed that Leonard Rizzo was off the hook, he was arrested on May 21, 1999 for possession of methamphetamines. Suddenly suspicions returned to Rizzo, as evidence of drug use had also been found in June 1997 when his home was first investigated by police. Now Rizzo was living in a San Antonio trailer park.

Even before Rizzo could be tried for drug possession, a neighbor called SAPD on the night of June 1, 1999 to report a bloody, half-naked woman running down the street away from a mobile home. Police arrived on the scene to find Leonard Rizzo holed up in the trailer he owned, his battered girlfriend frantically telling police what Leonard had done to her. The girlfriend claimed that she and Leonard were doing meth, when Rizzo allegedly threatened the woman with chopping her up and burying her in a bag in the backyard. The woman claimed that Leonard beat her that night, and had even accused her at one point of killing Rizzo's wife back in 1997.

After a 4-hour standoff, Leonard Rizzo finally emerged from the trailer--armed with a handgun. He allegedly fired a shot in the air before aiming it at SAPD officers. One of the officers then fired, hitting Rizzo in the stomach. Rizzo, still alive, was sent to the hospital and charged with Assault with a Deadly Weapon, drug possession, domestic abuse and kidnapping.

I can only assume that Rizzo was convicted on at least one of these charges, but have not yet found any proof to support it. Does anyone out there have this proof? If Rizzo is in jail, how long is his sentance?

NEXT: Timeline in the Monika Rizzo case...

Death of Monika Rizzo


WHAT:  Missing Person; Unexplained Death
WHO:  Monika Rizzo, female, 44 years old
WHERE:  San Antonio, Texas
LAST SEEN:  around May 27, 1997
TIME OF DEATH (Estimated):  between May 12-July 4, 1997

CASE ABSTRACT:
Monika Rizzo left her place of employment at _________, San Antonio, TX around lunchtime on Monday, May 5, 1997, leaving her purse at her desk. She never returned to work, and was never seen again by any of her coworkers. Monika's employer, Gilbert Saenz, made repeated phone calls to the Rizzo home (4454 Forestgreen Drive, San Antonio, TX) for days to inquire as to why Monika had left and not returned to work, but no one answered the phone. Finally on Monday, May 12, Monika Rizzo answered a phone call from Saenz who asked her if she was ok, and when she would be returning to work. Monika stated that she was not feeling well, but would be returning to the office on Monday, May 19.

During the week of May 12, some of Monika's coworkers called the San Antonio Police Department (SAPD) to check on Monika at her home. An SAPD officer visited the home, and Monika answered the door. The officer reported that Monika had bruises on her face, and did not appear well. The officer told Monika that her coworkers had asked that SAPD check on her, and asked Monika if she was ok. Monika attributed her bruises to a fall, claimed that she was not feeling well, and that she was taking care of her husband who was also ill.

On Monday, May 19, Monika Rizzo failed to return to work as she had promised.

Robert Hakala, a friend of the Rizzo's, reported that he had visited and spoken to Monika and her husband, Leonard Rizzo, Sr. at their home sometime in late-May or early-June. This was the last time Hakala ever saw Monika alive. Hakula returned to the Rizzo home three days later to discover a foul odor apparently coming from the Rizzo property, and compared the smell to a "dead animal". Hakula then noticed a small dog in the Rizzo backyard, carrying what appeared to be a human jawbone in its mouth. Hakala inspected the jawbone and by the look of the bottom teeth, believed the jawbone to be that of Monika Rizzo. He returned to the Rizzo house the next day to find what looked to be a body under a blanket in the backyard, covered with tires.

The SAPD received a call from Leonard Rizzo, Jr. on June 5, 1997, who reported his mother missing. Leonard, Jr. stated that Monika Rizzo had not been seen since she left work on May 5. On June 5, SAPD dispatched officers to the Rizzo house to inquire about Monika's disappearance. Monika's car was in the driveway when police arrived. Leonard Rizzo, Jr. answered the door and allowed the SAPD officers to enter, whereupon the officers discovered Leonard Rizzo, Sr. on the living room couch, suffering from an apparent seizure. Paramedics took Leonard Rizzo, Sr. to the hospital, while SAPD officers discovered evidence of illegal drug use in the home. Leonard Rizzo, Jr. gave the officers permission to search the backyard, upon which a cow skull was found on the ground--no human remains were found.

On Friday, July 4, Robert Hakala called the SAPD Homicide Unit to report a murder, telling them they would find a body in the backyard of 4454 Forestgreen Drive, under a blanket and tires. That day, Leonard Rizzo, Sr. was interviewed by SAPD regarding his wife's disappearance. Rizzo stated that he woke up one morning around June 21 to find his wife gone. He stated that he never reported her missing because he was confident that she would return home on her own. During the interview, when Leonard Rizzo Sr. learned that SAPD did not suspect that Monika's disappearance constituted a capital crime, Leonard Rizzo Sr. was quoted by officers as saying, "Maybe I ought to go kill someone else."

On Monday, July 7, SAPD secured and executed a search warrant for 4454 Forestgreen Drive. Upon arriving at the house, SAPD officers found Leonard Rizzo, Jr.; his father, Leonard Sr. was not present, and Leonard Jr. gave the officers permission to search the property. Inside the home they found a section of damaged wall in the living room near the door to the garage, with blood residue on the wall. In the backyard, officers discovered human remains including hair, a skull and numerous bone fragments that appeared to have been chopped up by mechanical means. Some human hand bone fragments were found in the barbecue pit. Decaying human flesh was also discovered in a plastic bag near the skull. Also found in the backyard were a garbage disposal and a handsaw.

When the search warrant was officially filed on July 15, SAPD had reason to suspect that Monika Rizzo had been attacked inside the home (creating the broken and bloody drywall), and that she had probably been murdered and her body placed in the backyard. The remains were sent to GeneScreen Labs, Inc. in Dallas, TX for DNA testing; the result was that the bones belonged to 3 unidentified people, but not Monika Rizzo.

During the week of August 1, archaeologists from the University of Texas at San Antonio excavated the Rizzo's backyard. Several hundred small human bone fragments were found, all of which were "sticky" to the touch as if the individual(s) had died recently. Some of the bone fragments (leg bones) found in this archaeological investigation were later tested against the DNA of Leonard Rizzo Sr.'s two sons (Leonard Sr. and Vincent), as well as Monika's parents. GeneScreen Labs, Inc. found that those leg fragments indeed belonged to Monika Rizzo.

Monika Rizzo was legally declared dead in 1999, following DNA confirmation of her leg bone remains. SAPD has never determined Monika's cause of death, place of death, or time of death. Additionally, SAPD has never been able to account for, or identify the bones of the 3 other individuals found in the backyard; it has been suggested that perhaps all of the bones found at 4454 Forestgreen Drive are indeed Monika Rizzo's, and that the initial lab identifications of 3 unknown persons may have been wholly inaccurate--perhaps tainted by the DNA of the investigators handling the bones. In an interview with Unsolved Mysteries in 1998, Leonard Rizzo, Sr. maintained that he has no idea where Monika Rizzo went, and stated that an unknown person or persons must have buried the bones in his backyard in attempt to frame him with his wife's murder.

UP NEXT:  Update on Leonard Rizzo, Sr.: More Trouble With the Law

____________________________________________________________________

SOURCES:

Affadavit for Search Warrant, SAPD, Filed July 15, 1997, Case #97-W-0273:
http://bbs.clutchfans.net/archive/index.php/t-61451.html

"Experts identify bones as Rizzo's Remains from 3 others also found in back yard." (article) San Antonio Express-News, by Brenda Rodriguez and Marty Sabota:
http://bbs.clutchfans.net/archive/index.php/t-61451.html

Unsolved Mysteries, "Backyard Bones" (television show, 1998):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Ht6PWJwA2I

Introduction

Hello web sleuths, and welcome to my blog, Cold Case Crimes. Its purpose is to educate the public and help renew interest in cold cases, with the long-term goal of solving them. I will be presenting the known facts of various unsolved murder and missing persons cases, citing all relevant sources possible. I encourage one and all to contribute their thoughts and deductions on this blog; an interested and involved public goes a long way in solving these cases. And if anyone wants to add a new cold case here, please let me know.

I welcome all comments and discussion on this blog, with these simple rules in mind:
(1) Responses should be directly related to the specific case being discussed, unless someone is suggesting a new case to be discussed.
(2) Please do your best to cite the source of all case information you refer to. It really helps to keep information direct; as we know many cases are bungled by innacuracies and circumstantial evidence.
(3) No obscenity or profanity is allowed in comments; those that are will be deleted.

Thanks! So let's get started!