Friday, April 1, 2011

Ricky McCormick: Mysterious Death Encoded?












An Appeal by the FBI
On March 30, 2011, the FBI issued a call for cryptographers to assist their investigation of the supposed 1999 murder of one Ricky McCormick (pictured here). McCormick, 41, was found dead in a field near West Alton, MO in July 1999. On McCormick's person were two handwritten notes, both written in what appears to be a code or cipher. The FBI believes Ricky wrote these notes up to 3 days before his death; by releasing the notes (pictured below), the FBI hopes that a translation may help them figure out what happened to McCormick.


The Evidence
Ricky McCormick was last seen alive on June 25, 1999 when he visited Forest Park Hospital in St. Louis to obtain medication for chronic heart and lung problems. His dead body was found on Wednesday, June 30, 1999, lying near the southeast corner of a cornfield, not far from a wooded railroad bed just west of Highway 367. The body was decomposed to the point that the deceased had probably been dead for at least two days; his identity was confirmed by his fingerprint. At first it appeared as though McCormick may have had physical damage to his head, though the Coroner later found no evidence of obvious life-endangering injuries such as knife wounds or gunshots. Authorities remain uncertain as to whether Ricky was murdered or not; no cause of death was ever determined, and the body's advanced state of decomposition hindered their efforts. Some of the only evidence found at the scene were the two notes in McCormick's pocket, which were presumably written by him. West Alton Police and St. Charles County Police, in speaking with McCormick's parents, determined that family and friends knew Ricky had written messages in code since his youth. But no one claimed to have known how to read these codes.

Who was Ricky McCormick?
He was born in St. Louis in 1957 or 1958, and attended public school before dropping out of high school around 1975. Though Ricky quit school, family and friends described him as "street smart". Authorities determined that McCormick had three addresses in the St. Louis area, including 1400 Choteau Avenue in St. Louis, and several Illinois addresses. Missouri court records show that McCormick had financial trouble and was evicted from an apartment in the St. Louis area. Ricky had a criminal history in the area, including a charge of statutory rape, for which he served 11 months in jail. He was known to have fathered four children, though he never married. At the time of his death, McCormick was unemployed and living on disability welfare. McCormick's apparent reliance on writing codes for himself may indicate a private personality-- perhaps to hide information from others, or maybe to exercise a kind of personal intelligence.

Ricky's Writing Style
Authorities investigating Ricky's death could not find any other examples of Ricky's writing, besides the two notes found on his person. He was literate, and could not have made it to high school without being able to read and write in English.
The two pages exhibit similar writing, a right-leaning script using all capital letters, indicative of a literate, right-handed male. Both notes seem to have been written by the same hand. Each page's text is penned in strings of continuous characters--most being letters, but some numbers, parentheses, a few hyphens and one apostrophe. A character which appears to be "N" is written smaller and more quickly than other characters, and may represent not an "N" but rather something else, such as a line break. The letter "E" is the last letter of many "words" throughout the script, and many consonants are mixed in. Many "words" are repeated.
Despite the fact that many believe these passages to be in cipher or code, the text of both pages appear almost readable and may be written in a phonetic format. Again, Ricky was literate, so these two notes may represent a personal "shorthand" notation that Ricky developed. Let's now look at the text of the messages, before analyzing the code and shorthand possibilities, the "language" Ricky used in his writing.

Page 1
The page that authorities refer to as "Page 1" (noted by the circled "P1" in the upper-right hand corner of the page), appears to be written in ballpoint ink on a blank piece of unlined paper. The "message" fills up only the top half of the sheet of paper. Though most characters are strung together in 13 "lines" which appear to form "paragraphs", whole lines and portions of lines are encased in parentheses. The "title line" (top line) is indented, as are lines 7-13. The increasing indentations toward the end of this note give the appearance of songwriting, poetry or other lyrical notation of some sort.
Here is the Page 1 manuscript, typed in similar format and spacing to the actual page:

    (MNDMKNEARSE-N-S-M-KNARE)         (A(SM))
TFRHENPINSENPBSERCBBNSE NPRSE INC
PRSE N MRSE DPRE HLDWLDNCBE(TFXLF TCXL N CBE)
AL-PRPPIT XLYPPIY N CBE MGKSEWCDRCBRNSEPRSE
WLDRCBRNSE N T SSHENTXSE-CRSLE-CLTRSEWLDNCBE
ALWLDNCBETSME LRSE RLSE URGLNE AS N WLD N CBE
  (NOPFSE NLSRE NCBE) NTEGDDMNSENCURERCBRNE
              (TENE TFRNE NCBRTSE N CBE INC)
                       (FLRSE PQSE ONDE71 NCBE)
                       (CDNSE PRSE ONSDE74 NCBE)
                       (PRTSE PRSE ON REDE 75 N CBE)
(TF NQCMSP SOLE MRDE LUSE TOTE WLD N WLDNCBE)
                                           (194 WLD’S NCBE) (TRFXL)

Page 2
"Page 2", featuring what appear to be paragraphs that are circled and thus isolated from other paragraphs, was also written in ballpoint ink like Page 1. But this page's text was written on blank, unlined stationery marked "NOTES" at the top of the page. Page 2's stationery may have been old generic note paper (or a newer printing of a classic style), as evidenced by the "Art Deco" appearance of the font of "NOTES". This page's writing covers roughly the top 75% of the sheet.
Here is the Page 2 manuscript, typed in similar format and spacing to the actual page:

AL PNTE GLSE-SE ERTE
VLSE MTSE-CTSE-WSE-FRTSE
PNRTRSE ONDRSEWLD NCBE
NWLDZLRCMSPNEWLDSTSMEXL
         DULMT6TUNSE NCBEXC

          (MUNSAISTENMUNARSE)
KLSE-LRSTE-TRSE-TRSE-MKSEN-MRSE
          (SAE6NSE SE NMBSE)

NMNRCBRNSEPTE2PTEWSREBKNSE
26MLSE74SPRKSE29KENOSOLE173RTRSE
356LE CLGSEOUNUTKEDKRSE PSESHLE
651MTCSEHTLSENCUTCTRS NMRE
99.84.5 5UNEPLSENCRSEADLTSENSKSENBSE
NSREONSE PVTSEWLDNCBE (3XORL)
NMSENRSEIN2NTRLERCBRNSENTSRCRBNE
LSPNSENGSPSEMKSEKBSEPCBEAVXL’R
HMCRENMREFCBE          1/2MUNDPLSE
     D-W-M-4HIL XDRLX


Code or Shorthand?
Since the FBI's online posting of these two notes online on March 28, 2011, the notes have generated many theories of interpretation among the online community.The FBI and many others undoubtedly have been examining the texts for a code or cipher solution. Still others believe Ricky's work to be in a personal "shorthand" notation.

Code Theory
Some believe that these notes are written in code. One person found that part of the Page 2 code uses letters preceding the letter "N", and that these characters spell out "DEPEW", followed by an 877 area code phone number. This person found that "Depew" was the last name of a doctor working in a St. Louis area mental hospital, and that the phone number (decoded from counting the number position of letters in the alphabet), matches that of the mental facility.

Shorthand Theory
Others have come to see these cryptic messages as a form of shorthand, rather than a coded form of writing. Some think that these long "sentences" and "paragraphs" could rather be a list of part numbers, or job descriptions for repair work. Some point to the VIN-like appearance of sentences, and the terms "SL", "SE" and "XL" as maybe referring to certain automobiles. Others note the frequent appearance of letters "N", "S", and "E", as well as what might be highway/road or exit numbers, and believe these may be driving directions, written quickly in shorthand format as if Ricky were writing from someone's telephone dictation. Someone looked at the three farthest-indented lines of Page 1 and believed that perhaps these three lines listed certain people Ricky had some contact or experience with at certain times; the first (Line 9) appears to say "First person De(cember) (19)71 NCBE"; Line 10, "Second person De(cember) (19)74 NCBE". At least one observer has suggested that some "words" (like "NCBE") may refer to street names for illegal drugs, assuming that Ricky may have been dealing drugs and was keeping memos of customers, their orders and recognizable characteristics. Yet with all these shorthand theories, many internet sleuths are now focusing their attention on the possibility that these shorthand notes are song or poetry lyrics, as many words in sentences rhyme when spoken phonetically. Could he have been writing rap songs or making up song lyrics as many people often do? One internet sleuth posted a note to the "Ricky McCormick Murder Notes" Wikipedia page, giving a loose interpretation of the notes from "pigeon English" (the note was later disputed and deleted due to its lack of factual content). This contributor claims that McCormick wrote in a style similar to that of people with psychological problems, and his loose "phonetic" translation of the notes included many strange religious and/or mythical events and states of mind.
And some point out the possibility that McCormick's jumbled placement of letters within sentences, which complicates a straight phonetic interpretation of the writing, could reveal that the author was dyslexic.

Conclusion
The FBI's publishing of these two notes has prompted many interpretation efforts by the public online community, and this outpouring of ideas may eventually shed light on the mysterious death of Ricky McCormick. While the FBI stated its hope that someone will "decipher" the notes, it is unlikely they will be if indeed these notes are coded, as top cryptologists have failed to do so. If no "code key" or other writing examples were found among McCormick's belongings, the "code" will probably never be solved. Most likely the "code" is actually in a form of personalized phonetic and/or symbolic shorthand, which may not be so hard to decipher.
But in any case, I find it unfortunate that more details on Ricky McCormick's life and crime scene evidence have not been available via the internet. If more is revealed, law enforcement in Missouri as well as the FBI may be able to solve the mystery of Ricky's death with the help of the concerned public. I believe it is their only chance.